The Beatles or The Stones?

Jake McHale wrote:

Soul Kitchen wrote:

Breadman wrote:

wessy wrote: Its always Beatle mania not stones Mania

Was it not just all teenage girls screaming and wetting their knickers?

They were just the One Direction of their day, surely....?

At last somebody who sees it as it is!
And add T Rex to the gusset dampening brigade!!

Absolute fucking idiots especially SK how the fuck can anyone compare 1D to the Beatles is beyond belief you fucking moron you have no credibility at all .Your taste in music is shit, I bet your fucking dustman sings Hey Jude better in your mind you absolute Bellend what a fucking clown you are you know fuck all about music beyond your wierd obscure shit that next to nobody gives a shit about.

Breadman wrote:

Gary Barlow's a miles better songwriter than either Lennon 

Breadman wrote:Come on, Jake.....be serious for a minute now.

It's a well documented fact nowadays that Brian Epstein put The Beatles together because he wanted a boy-band in the Westlife / Take That mould that he could use to cash in on the chart success that Gerry & The Pacemakers and The Merseybeats were having at that time.

They were aimed squarely at the teenage girl market because they were the ones buying records.

Surely even you have to admit that's true....?

And let's be honest, Let It Be's not a terrible tune but it's nowhere near the quality of say Back For Good or Take That And Party, is it?

Gary Barlow's a miles better songwriter than either Lennon or McCartney - just look at the Ivor Novello awards he's won and the number of records he's sold.

Soul Kitchen wrote:

y2johnny wrote:

The beatles even broke america.

And so did Led Zeppelin on a bigger stage!!
And arguably the biggest band Britain ever produced!

Soul Kitchen wrote:

Jake McHale wrote:

Soul Kitchen wrote:

Breadman wrote:

wessy wrote: Its always Beatle mania not stones Mania

Was it not just all teenage girls screaming and wetting their knickers?

They were just the One Direction of their day, surely....?

At last somebody who sees it as it is!
And add T Rex to the gusset dampening brigade!!

Absolute fucking idiots especially SK how the fuck can anyone compare 1D to the Beatles is beyond belief you fucking moron you have no credibility at all .Your taste in music is shit, I bet your fucking dustman sings Hey Jude better in your mind you absolute Bellend what a fucking clown you are you know fuck all about music beyond your wierd obscure shit that next to nobody gives a shit about.

Oh dear, mind your blood pressure AD!
Read the post properly, I never mentioned 1D, but to me they have similar significance!!!
Music is all objective and personal opinion, the only fucking morons, as you put it, are the people that can't see that?
Not as you can't, of course, AD.
As for my dustman and Hey Jude, never see him so I'll pass on that, but Picket sings it the best!

finlaymcdanger wrote:The Damned
The Rolling Stones
The Beetles

In that order

Jake McHale wrote:

Soul Kitchen wrote:

y2johnny wrote:

The beatles even broke america.

And so did Led Zeppelin on a bigger stage!!
And arguably the biggest band Britain ever produced!

LZ mainly forgotten now,Beatles Timeless.

Jake McHale wrote:

Soul Kitchen wrote:

y2johnny wrote:

The beatles even broke america.

And so did Led Zeppelin on a bigger stage!!
And arguably the biggest band Britain ever produced!

LZ mainly forgotten now,Beatles Timeless.

Jake McHale wrote:

Soul Kitchen wrote:

Jake McHale wrote:

Soul Kitchen wrote:

Breadman wrote:

wessy wrote: Its always Beatle mania not stones Mania

Was it not just all teenage girls screaming and wetting their knickers?

They were just the One Direction of their day, surely....?

At last somebody who sees it as it is!
And add T Rex to the gusset dampening brigade!!

Absolute fucking idiots especially SK how the fuck can anyone compare 1D to the Beatles is beyond belief you fucking moron you have no credibility at all .Your taste in music is shit, I bet your fucking dustman sings Hey Jude better in your mind you absolute Bellend what a fucking clown you are you know fuck all about music beyond your wierd obscure shit that next to nobody gives a shit about.

Oh dear, mind your blood pressure AD!
Read the post properly, I never mentioned 1D, but to me they have similar significance!!!
Music is all objective and personal opinion, the only fucking morons, as you put it, are the people that can't see that?
Not as you can't, of course, AD.
As for my dustman and Hey Jude, never see him so I'll pass on that, but Picket sings it the best!

Wilson shitits version is at best crap.

Breadman wrote:Ok, Nat:

Fear Of A Black Planet or Straight Outta Compton?

And I want three reasons to substantiate your answer.

(For me, PE shade it but only just.)

Natasha Whittam wrote:

Breadman wrote:Ok, Nat:

Fear Of A Black Planet or Straight Outta Compton?

And I want three reasons to substantiate your answer.

(For me, PE shade it but only just.)

Take 'Fuck Tha Police' and the title track out of Straight Outta Compton and you've got a very weak album. Fear Of A Black Planet is full of crackers - so on a musical level it wins every time.

Lyrically NWA were one dimensional and obsessed with bitches and hoes. And while PE weren't above a bit of sexism they generally wrote fantastic lyrics with meaning.

Reason 3: Chuck D.