Natasha Whittam wrote: largehat wrote:I have made a formal complaint to the BBC about Alan Shearer in the past, and another about Garth Crooks.
Can you post a copy of your letter to the BBC, I would love to read that.
I'm sure you would, but it's on an old laptop which has since died. I could fanny about and get it off the hard drive but I can't be bothered.
Happy to explain what the complaints were about though. I accused both Crooks and Shearer of being in breach of the BBC Trust directive that the BBC should be impartial.
I saw my arse last season over two incidents which followed in fairly quick succession.
Crooks was in the Football Focus studio last season the day we lost at Liverpool to a suspected offside goal in the last minute. Crooks was delighted and actually said these words, "there's a suspicion of offside about the goal but who cares?". I went MENTAL.
A week or two later, we lost at Chelsea to a Drogba goal that again looked offside. On MOTD, Shearer said "it wasn't offside, simple as that" and then showed one of those graphics with a line drawn on it which supposedly proved Drogba was further from the goal than the last defender. The thing is though that the line was clearly and blatantly not parallel with the halfway line which was also visible in the shot.
So I accused both of them of unacceptable bias. In Crooks case they replied saying no BBC pundits are biased and it is their job to call it how they see it.
In Shearer's case they admitted the graphic looked wrong but that this was an accident, they would check the machine that does the graphics and denied my allegation that he was fabricating evidence.