An oldie that always seems to slip under the radar - even though he's remained around football for donkeys years is Gordon Taylor OBE, CEO of the PFA. He played over 250 times for us and scored about 50 goals as a winger. What I liked about him (apart from being part of a really great Wanderers team) was that he was a fat barsteward and seemed to have a beer belly supported by matchstick legs, but could still shift a bit, great crosser and a good shot.
He just didn't look like a professional footballer, let alone a pacy winger but he did the business.