Bolton Wanderers Football Club Fan Forum for all BWFC Supporters.


You are not connected. Please login or register

First it was "Post Truth" and now this......

+9
gloswhite
boltonbonce
wanderlust
Fabians Right Peg
xmiles
Soul Kitchen
karlypants
Natasha Whittam
Bread2.0
13 posters

Go to page : Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next

Go down  Message [Page 3 of 4]

Bread2.0

Bread2.0
Andy Walker
Andy Walker

gloswhite wrote:I like the Poles. They helped us out during the war, and as you say, they are good workers. Its a shame that a lot of our own workers had to take a dive in wages when the market was flooded with all the cheaper, but still skilled, workers.

No offence, Glos, but that is a myth.

And it's that myth which helps to perpetuate the lie that your average British worker is poorer now because he's competing with some Polish bloke.

I used to work for a company in Manchester who have a large factory which makes washing up liquid, bleach and fabric conditioner.

They employ about 300 people in their Filling Hall across four shifts.

The nature of seasonal demand dictates that they employ a percentage of that number on agency contracts, so that they can flex up and down as appropriate.

The going rate for the job (when I was there) was about seven quid an hour.

They have a retained agency on site who source and provide said labour.

And they struggle to employ local (English) people because quite a lot of the residents of Langley Estate in Middleton won't get out of bed for seven quid an hour, let alone work on a production line, filling bottles of bleach.

So how do they fill the labour gap?

By bringing Eastern Europeans in, that's how.

And the decent ones are offered permanent contracts after 12 weeks.

So over the last ten years or so, the factory dynamic has shifted a bit to the point where about 50% of the full time, permanent staff are Eastern Europeans.

And this myth keeps getting perpetuated locally that McBrides only employ Poles and you can't get on if you're English and that's racist, blah, blah, etc....

When the truth of the matter actually is that McBride's would love a factory full of English people because it would make keeping the place running over Christmas far easier because 50% of the workforce wouldn't be buggering off back to Gdansk for the holidays.

And the Poles haven't driven the wages down, they're just more willing to accept the going rate for the job, whereas Daz from Midd would rather stay in bed and get his weed money off the government once a fortnight. 

And having been self-employed for the last 12 years or so, I've seen this in literally dozens of factories up and down the country.

I've said it before, if they all upped sticks and went home tomorrow, half our factories would shut almost over night and the other half would have to start putting their prices up to offset the increase in wages that they'd have to offer Daz and his mates to get them off benefits.

And that ain't sustainable.

Bit it would be a direct consequence of abandoning the free movement of Europe wide labour which so many Leavers see as a good thing.

Natasha Whittam

Natasha Whittam
Nat Lofthouse
Nat Lofthouse

Bread2.0 wrote:I get what you're saying, Glos, honestly, I do but, again, I can only comment from my own experience.

And I know personally, many people who voted Leave because they "don't like pakkies because they're all paedos" and will openly admit this now with a smile on their face.


Where do you know these people from, the Walkden branch of the KKK?

Natasha Whittam

Natasha Whittam
Nat Lofthouse
Nat Lofthouse

Bread2.0 wrote:
And the Poles haven't driven the wages down, they're just more willing to accept the going rate for the job, whereas Daz from Midd would rather stay in bed and get his weed money off the government once a fortnight. 

Is "Daz" you?

Bread2.0

Bread2.0
Andy Walker
Andy Walker

In chronological order, the answers are:

I'm related by marriage to about six of them. 

and

No.

gloswhite

gloswhite
Guðni Bergsson
Guðni Bergsson

Breaders, what you say is true, however, you are talking about unskilled labour. A point you miss is that as soon as a vacancy arises, there are more than enough Poles, Eastern Europeans, or whatever, available. I wouldn't have thought that all these people are working whilst they are waiting for the vacancy. I remember seeing TV programmes where skilled manual workers are being constantly undercut on prices, etc. When I was having my extension built, over six months, not once was a Pole on site, and one day there were 11 people here. 
Not all the locals want to stay in bed, but as you point out, a lot of them are stuck in the benefits trap, although I do wonder how whole sections of society can survive on lower wages, and some can't.
if there was a pub around the corner, I'm sure we'd have a damned good discussion  Very Happy

xmiles

xmiles
Jay Jay Okocha
Jay Jay Okocha

Natasha Whittam wrote:
xmiles wrote:when large numbers of people have voted to make things worse for themselves.

It statements like this from the Remain camp that anger me.

Firstly xmiles, please tell me how voting to leave the EU has made things worse for me. I don't mean a general sweeping statement, I mean for me personally.

Secondly, leaving the EU is a long term strategy, I firmly believe that in 20 years time the UK will be far stronger because of it. Unless you have a time machine please tell me how you know I am wrong.

1. It may not make things worse for you if you are reasonably wealthy. I never said or implied that it will be worse for everybody. However if you are living in a region or working in an industry such as farming which receives large EU subsidies you are probably going to be worse off. Similarly employees are likely to see their work conditions deteriorate as some of the protections introduced by the EU are removed. Inflation will go up as the cost of importing goods rises due to the drop in the value of the pound. This will almost certainly get worse if we leave the single market.

2. I can't tell you that you are wrong. 20 years is a long time. You may even be right. Shocked

okocha

okocha
El Hadji Diouf
El Hadji Diouf

gloswhite wrote:
okocha wrote:The saddest thing for me are the divisions in society that have been caused, including death threats made against some of the main protagonists. Through his fateful decision to hold a referendum, DC has created a massive rift in society that will be very slow to settle, whatever way it goes now. People will be arguing endlessly about strategies for EU negotiations and outcomes.

 To make it worse, the handling of the key issues from the outset was shameful, so that no one could be certain of the likely consequences of their voting. No wonder people are disenchanted with politicians. Lies and exaggeration at every turn.

Nearly half the population will be unhappy now, as is also the case in America, but while DC is lying low and escaping most of the flak, Trump gets Time Magazine's Man of the Year award for being even more blatantly a dissembler, and continues to make errors of judgement that may eventually prove catastrophic.

Thank God BW are cheering us up for the moment!
Agree with you Okocha, but there were already big divisions in the country, and thats, why the referendum went the way it did. I also believe it will take a long time for this situation to resolve, but whilst we argue among ourselves, the pain will be prolonged for all.
I honestly thought the Times awarding Trump the Man of the year award was a piss take, as the nominations were him, Farage, and Putin, but when I saw on the TV that they were taking it seriously, I couldn't help but wonder where society was going. Its as stupid as giving Obama the Nobel prize when he hadn't done anything.
As you say, at least we have the Super Whites to keep us going.  Very Happy
Glos, the award was not from The Times, but given annually by Time Magazine, an American publication. Still controversial, though!

okocha

okocha
El Hadji Diouf
El Hadji Diouf

The number of wild suppositions and generalisations on this thread is stupefying. The whole issue is far more complex than can be explained by mentioning some people that you are acquainted with and then making them your "truth". 

Nor do the figures quoted by Wander begin to explain people's individual motives for their choice on the absurdly simplistic referendum voting form. (Thanks, Dave!) You are just guessing.

The fact that British society and institutions, our elected representatives in government, each political party etc....(in fact, EVERYbody)....  are so divided, confirms that we should refrain from making sweeping statements that are simply expressions of our own point of view.

Boggersbelief

Boggersbelief
Nat Lofthouse
Nat Lofthouse

Bread2.0 wrote:
Natasha Whittam wrote:
xmiles wrote:when large numbers of people have voted to make things worse for themselves.

It statements like this from the Remain camp that anger me.

Firstly xmiles, please tell me how voting to leave the EU has made things worse for me. I don't mean a general sweeping statement, I mean for me personally.


He didn't mention you though, did he?

He said "large numbers of people", so unless you're one of the racist scrotes who left school at 16 with no qualifications and who now hate Polish people for making you look bad with their protestant work ethic and can-do attitude, as you sit on your settee all day, watching Kyle and eating Pot Noodles paid for with your JSA, that I keep referring to.....

....his point stands.

And I agree with him.

Doesn't everyone leave school at 16?

gloswhite

gloswhite
Guðni Bergsson
Guðni Bergsson

okocha wrote:
gloswhite wrote:
okocha wrote:The saddest thing for me are the divisions in society that have been caused, including death threats made against some of the main protagonists. Through his fateful decision to hold a referendum, DC has created a massive rift in society that will be very slow to settle, whatever way it goes now. People will be arguing endlessly about strategies for EU negotiations and outcomes.

 To make it worse, the handling of the key issues from the outset was shameful, so that no one could be certain of the likely consequences of their voting. No wonder people are disenchanted with politicians. Lies and exaggeration at every turn.

Nearly half the population will be unhappy now, as is also the case in America, but while DC is lying low and escaping most of the flak, Trump gets Time Magazine's Man of the Year award for being even more blatantly a dissembler, and continues to make errors of judgement that may eventually prove catastrophic.

Thank God BW are cheering us up for the moment!
Agree with you Okocha, but there were already big divisions in the country, and thats, why the referendum went the way it did. I also believe it will take a long time for this situation to resolve, but whilst we argue among ourselves, the pain will be prolonged for all.
I honestly thought the Times awarding Trump the Man of the year award was a piss take, as the nominations were him, Farage, and Putin, but when I saw on the TV that they were taking it seriously, I couldn't help but wonder where society was going. Its as stupid as giving Obama the Nobel prize when he hadn't done anything.
As you say, at least we have the Super Whites to keep us going.  Very Happy
Glos, the award was not from The Times, but given annually by Time Magazine, an American publication. Still controversial, though!
Sorry mate. I was so busy typing that I wasn't reading it. I did of course mean Time magazine, or was it the Beano...... ?  Very Happy

boltonbonce

boltonbonce
Nat Lofthouse
Nat Lofthouse

The Beano is much the better read. Stinkbomb Stan caused mayhem this week when William and Kate arrived to open a new flower bed.

gloswhite

gloswhite
Guðni Bergsson
Guðni Bergsson

I might just go and buy a copy now  Very Happy

boltonbonce

boltonbonce
Nat Lofthouse
Nat Lofthouse

gloswhite wrote:I might just go and buy a copy now  Very Happy
Subscribe,like me. You save a packet. 

https://www.beano.com/subscribe

gloswhite

gloswhite
Guðni Bergsson
Guðni Bergsson

Was looking through the Beano and Dandy annual yesterday, in Asda, (for my grandson of course)

Bread2.0

Bread2.0
Andy Walker
Andy Walker

Oi!

Serious thread!

No Forsyth, no comics and definitely no fucking pandas!

wanderlust

wanderlust
Nat Lofthouse
Nat Lofthouse

okocha wrote:
Nor do the figures quoted by Wander begin to explain people's individual motives for their choice on the absurdly simplistic referendum voting form. (Thanks, Dave!) You are just guessing.
Whilst we will never know every individual's motives for voting the way they did, the analysis of the various surveys published the other day would seem to be a fair indicator of the more common motives as the sample size was in excess of 40,000 therefore I would disagree with your assertion that it's guesswork.

I published the figures in the economy thread as "the economy" was a massive factor in the decision making process (along with immigration and what is described as"taking back control") so please have a look.

Agree that the referendum form was too simplistic - in fact I'd go as far as to say that they asked the wrong question. Currently the Government are in the courts arguing about leaving the single market (they are avoiding saying that for political reasons) but we all know the problem is because nobody was asked if they wanted to leave the market, incorrect assumptions were made and there was no explanation of the implications of leaving prior to the referendum. It's like they asked if we wanted to leave the wife and after everybody said yes, then asked "even if she's taking the house, the car, your penis and all your money?"

The Government's current position is "you said you wanted to leave your wife so you won't mind if I evict you from your house, sell your car, cut off your penis and transfer all your money into her account".

boltonbonce

boltonbonce
Nat Lofthouse
Nat Lofthouse

Bread2.0 wrote:Oi!

Serious thread!

Razz

Bread2.0

Bread2.0
Andy Walker
Andy Walker

Interesting to note that in his list of things he wouldn't want to lose in a divorce, Lusty's penis ranks only third behind his house and his car.

He must drive a really nice car.......

Natasha Whittam

Natasha Whittam
Nat Lofthouse
Nat Lofthouse

I can't believe he didn't mention his armchair.

okocha

okocha
El Hadji Diouf
El Hadji Diouf

Lusty: your own words undermine your assertions and sweeping generalisations about the voting motives of over 17 million people.

would seem to be a fair indicator of the more common motives"  Hardly convincing! Floundering convictions?


You're not in any position to presume to be able to judge everyone. Nor is anyone else. That's why there is still debate and uncertainty.......but this is boring now. Let's give it a rest!

Sponsored content



Back to top  Message [Page 3 of 4]

Go to page : Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum