Would you have Allardyce back?

Allardyce and Gartside can't work together so its one or the other, no one will miss Garty but that would be up to the owner to remove him. I would also doubt that Sam would return as he has a lot to lose reputation wise and little to gain by coming back, if things went pear shaped his "Legend" status would disappear very quickly and fans expectations would be high.

I have a feeling that the managerial merry go round will kick off in the Premier League come the summer, if Moyes leaves Everton BSA could well replace him.

He wouldn't have the same success if he ever came back IMO.

I agree. I don't think the market is there now. Look at Sam having to resort to bringing in our cast-aways.

Would have him back tomorrow.Best manager we have ever had or ever likely to have in the future. Coyle,Freedman not fit to lace his boots.

This old chestnut. If Allardyce had remained our manager we would be bankrupt by now.

Bernard Dennis Park wrote:I'd rather have Rioch back than fatty.

Seconded, Wet Spam are not doing to well.

I would but i dont know if it would work, there's an old saying never go back and it generally works out that way.

Angry Dad wrote:I would but i dont know if it would work, there's an old saying never go back and it generally works out that way.

It worked out quite well for pienaar at everton!

Boggersbelief wrote:

Angry Dad wrote:I would but i dont know if it would work, there's an old saying never go back and it generally works out that way.

It worked out quite well for pienaar at everton!

I'm talking managers not player's, its not the same.

Darren ferguson?

Like someone said, you should never go back. IT rarely works out. Why tarnish all the good work he did at the club?

It would be nigh on impossible for him to return- but I would have him back tomorrow. We had the best years in decades with Sam at the helm -and if he could reproduce half that magic, I would welcome it

I'd have him back, just for the fitness and organisation of the team.

YES !

Yes please.

Sam brought some great players to the club and gave us some memorable seasons. I'd have him back tomorrow.

I'd like the glory days again, but I am confident Freedman can be a success...

Natasha Whittam wrote:If Fat Sam had been manager these last two season we'd be a mid table Premier League club now.

Spot On! BSA would not allow pansies on the pitch. We have too many players on the pitch who only want to collect their wages rather than play hard.

Well most of us can dream eh!!!!