Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide.

Guest · 1 Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:19

Guest

I'm starting this thread to settle a dispute between Boggers and Scott.

It's quite simple: Anelka or Klasnic - Who's the better striker?

(The answer is obviously Anelka but let's indulge Scott for a bit.)

One vote each, don't waste it trying to be "ironic" and "clever" by voting for Klasnic.

Boggersbelief · 2 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:20

Boggersbelief

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 13258
Join date : 2012-08-07
Age : 32
Location : Everywhere.

Anelka. Best striker ever to play for Bolton wanderers. One of the best strikers the prem has seen

scottjames30 · 3 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:23

scottjames30

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 14235
Join date : 2013-02-17
Age : 108
Location : Top Dog.

Klasnic is a better striker, Anelka is a better player.

Stats don't lie.

karlypants · 4 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:25

karlypants

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 38249
Join date : 2012-08-04

Anelka for me as well.

Klasnic didn't have a bowel problem, it was his kidneys!

Boggersbelief · 5 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:26

Boggersbelief

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 13258
Join date : 2012-08-07
Age : 32
Location : Everywhere.

scottjames30 wrote:Klasnic is a better striker, Anelka is a better player.

Stats don't lie.

Anelka scored more goals!

scottjames30 · 6 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:27

scottjames30

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 14235
Join date : 2013-02-17
Age : 108
Location : Top Dog.

Boggersbelief wrote:

scottjames30 wrote:Klasnic is a better striker, Anelka is a better player.

Stats don't lie.

Anelka scored more goals!

I know, he played more games that's why.

Goals to mins on the pitch though.

Boggersbelief · 7 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:28

Boggersbelief

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 13258
Join date : 2012-08-07
Age : 32
Location : Everywhere.

Show me the goals to mins on pitch stats

Natasha Whittam · 8 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:30

Natasha Whittam

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 34087
Join date : 2012-01-04
Age : 40

Klasnic was a better finisher. Criminally underused in his time at Bolton.

boltonbonce · 9 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:32

boltonbonce

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 31144
Join date : 2013-10-05
Age : 71
Location : Pooh Corner

Anelka.

As for colostomy bags,I get the impression most of our present lot are wearing them.

They're taking the piss. Literally.

Boggersbelief · 10 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:33

Boggersbelief

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 13258
Join date : 2012-08-07
Age : 32
Location : Everywhere.

Natasha Whittam wrote:Klasnic was a better finisher. Criminally underused in his time at Bolton.

You talk shit

scottjames30 · 11 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:34

scottjames30

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 14235
Join date : 2013-02-17
Age : 108
Location : Top Dog.

Klasnic scored more goals minute per goal, in a shitter team.

Guest · 12 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:37

Guest

scottjames30 wrote:Klasnic scored more goals minute per goal,

What does that even mean.....? scratch

scottjames30 · 13 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:39

scottjames30

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 14235
Join date : 2013-02-17
Age : 108
Location : Top Dog.

Breadman wrote:

scottjames30 wrote:Klasnic scored more goals minute per goal,

What does that even mean.....?

Goals per minutes on the pitch, take a percentage.

Natasha Whittam · 14 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:40

Natasha Whittam

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 34087
Join date : 2012-01-04
Age : 40

Boggersbelief wrote:

You talk shit

So bitter for one so young.

Klasnic hardly missed a chance, Anelka missed loads but played in a much better team so had loads of chances per game.

If Gary Madine played in the current Bolton team and scored 1 goal from 1 chance, and I played in a team with Messi, Bale, Ronaldo, Earnshaw etc and scored 3 goals from 12 chances does that make me the better striker?

Of course not.

Norpig · 15 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 18:09

Norpig

Nat Lofthouse

Posts : 17854
Join date : 2012-11-30
Age : 53
Location : Burnage, Manchester

Anelka was better in my opinion although i did like Klasnic as well but on pure ability and career it has to be Anelka

finlaymcdanger · 16 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 18:13

finlaymcdanger

Frank Worthington

Posts : 3231
Join date : 2012-11-06
Location : New York

Surely this answers it.
Anelka
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Klasnic
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Guest · 17 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 18:55

Guest

Agreed.

You don't get to play for Mumbai City if you're a mug. Very Happy

finlaymcdanger · 18 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 19:16

finlaymcdanger

Frank Worthington

Posts : 3231
Join date : 2012-11-06
Location : New York

Breadman wrote:Agreed.

You don't get to play for Mumbai City if you're a mug.

Exactly!

doffcocker · 19 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 19:18

doffcocker

Ivan Campo

Posts : 4968
Join date : 2012-01-06
Age : 32
Location : Halliwell

Most people tend to agree that playing with Klasnic was tantamount to playing with ten men, minus the fact he averaged about a goal every four matches.
Let's imagine for a minute he scored one goal every game. That's four times as many goals as he actually scored for us and with a lot more regularity, as he would often score two together then go months without scoring one.
If given the choice, would you start every match with a one goal advantage and a one man disadvantage? I don't think most people would, yet a lot of people seem to think we missed a trick not starting Klasnic every match.

Obviously Anelka was a million times the player Klasnic was. Klasnic is phenomenally overrated at Bolton and I don't imagine us being an worse off had we never signed him.

Guest · 20 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 19:25

Guest

Throughout their careers Anelka would always create more chances for himself in a game than Klasnic ever could, his pace and movement were responsible for that hence he scored so many goals in his career and the talk of who's the better finisher is largely irrelevant.

I was a fan of Klasnic but by the time he reached us he'd never have made it as a regular Premier League stater, his partnership with Ailton at Bremen was a bit legendary though so maybe he had moer to offer pre kidney ops.

Sponsored content

Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide.

1 Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:19

Guest

2 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:20

Boggersbelief

3 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:23

scottjames30

4 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:25

karlypants

5 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:26

Boggersbelief

6 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:27

scottjames30

7 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:28

Boggersbelief

8 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:30

Natasha Whittam

9 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:32

boltonbonce

10 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:33

Boggersbelief

11 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:34

scottjames30

12 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:37

Guest

13 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:39

scottjames30

14 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 17:40

Natasha Whittam

15 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 18:09

Norpig

16 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 18:13

finlaymcdanger

17 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 18:55

Guest

18 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 19:16

finlaymcdanger

19 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 19:18

doffcocker

20 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide. Wed Nov 04 2015, 19:25

Guest

21 Re: Anelka Vs Klasnic - You decide.

Sponsored content